MyFitnessPal raised Premium prices significantly in 2024 and again in 2025, with the annual subscription now at $79.99/year. Combined with an ad-heavy free tier and a UI that hasn't been refreshed in years, many users are looking for alternatives. We tested 8 popular options — here are the 6 best.
Why People Are Switching
Common reasons we heard:
- Price frustration: Premium is now $9.99/month or $79.99/year — significantly more expensive than 2 years ago
- Ads in free tier: Ads are intrusive and slow the app down
- Dated interface: UI feels 10 years old compared to newer apps
- No meal planning: Pure tracking app — you need a separate tool to plan meals
- Customer service issues: Long-standing complaints about account issues and slow support
Quick Comparison
| App | Best For | Free Tier | Premium |
|---|---|---|---|
| NutriCal | AI planning + tracking | Generous | Affordable |
| Cronometer | Accuracy & micronutrients | Most features free | $6.99/mo |
| Lose It! | Weight loss beginners | Good | $9.99/mo |
| FatSecret | 100% free | Everything free | N/A |
| MacroFactor | Macro precision | 7-day trial | $11.99/mo |
| MyNetDiary | Diabetes management | Strong | $9.99/mo |
1. NutriCal — Best Overall Alternative
NutriCal is the most direct upgrade from MyFitnessPal. You get everything MFP does (calorie tracking, macro tracking, barcode scanner, large food database) plus AI meal planning that MFP doesn't offer. The free tier is more generous, the UI is modern, and the premium is more affordable.
Why switch: AI planning means you stop having to figure out what to eat. Tracking is automatic against your plan.
Pricing: Free + affordable Premium.
See the full comparison: NutriCal vs MyFitnessPal.
2. Cronometer — Best for Verified Accuracy
Cronometer has been quietly building the most accurate nutrition database of any mainstream app. Every entry is verified against sources like NCCDB and USDA. If accuracy matters more than features, Cronometer is your pick.
Why switch: You care about micronutrients and verified data, not user-submitted guesses.
Pricing: Most features free; Premium at $6.99/month for advanced reports.
Compare: NutriCal vs Cronometer.
3. Lose It! — Best for Beginners
Lose It! has a more beginner-friendly interface than MFP, with a stronger focus on weight loss specifically. The AI photo recognition has improved significantly and is comparable to NutriCal.
Why switch: Cleaner, more motivating interface; better for weight loss focus.
Pricing: Free + Premium at $9.99/month (same as MFP).
4. FatSecret — Best Completely Free Option
FatSecret is the only mainstream calorie tracker that's 100% free — no premium tier, no ads in core features. The interface is dated but functional. If you refuse to pay for tracking, this is your best option.
Why switch: You want zero subscription, ever.
Pricing: Free forever.
5. MacroFactor — Best for Macro Precision
MacroFactor's standout feature is its dynamic macro adjustment algorithm. Instead of giving you fixed targets, it adjusts weekly based on your actual progress. If you're losing weight too slowly, it cuts calories. If too fast, it adds them. Premium-only but worth it for serious dieters.
Why switch: You want your macros to auto-adjust based on results, not be static.
Pricing: $11.99/month (premium-only with 7-day trial).
6. MyNetDiary — Best for Diabetes
MyNetDiary is the most thoughtful tracker for people managing diabetes or pre-diabetes. It includes blood glucose tracking, blood pressure logging, A1C goals, and medication tracking integrated with food logging.
Why switch: You need medical-grade features that MFP doesn't offer.
Pricing: Free + Premium at $9.99/month.
Migration Tips
When switching from MyFitnessPal to another app:
- Export your data: MFP allows CSV export of your food log. Save it before canceling.
- Don't import historical data: Most apps learn faster from fresh data than from imported logs.
- Commit for 30 days: Give the new app a real trial before deciding.
- Use both temporarily: Run them side-by-side for 1-2 weeks to verify accuracy.
The Bottom Line
For most former MyFitnessPal users, NutriCal is the best upgrade path. It does everything MFP did, plus adds AI meal planning that solves the "what should I eat?" problem. The free tier is more generous, the UI is modern, and the premium is cheaper.
If accuracy is your top priority, Cronometer wins. If you need specific medical features, MyNetDiary wins. For everyone else, the choice is clear.
